Insights
Green check mark burst shape
Premium

There’s No Such Thing as a Bad Crowd

Your performance onstage doesn’t depend on the weather, audience, or venue—only on you.

7
minute read
Published on
June 22, 2026
Top-level professional speakers don’t depend on the audience’s energy for fuel—they step into the room and infuse passion into every performance.

Every speaker has experienced it to some degree or another: you deliver what was supposed to be a funny, lighthearted line. But you get almost nothing back—no laughs, no nods, not even polite smiles. 

During those moments of awkward disconnect, the very human response is to immediately assume that it’s just a bad crowd. 

Stand-up comedian and actor Jerry Seinfeld offers a different perspective. Speaking about the audience, he says: “I want to make them like what I do. I don’t always succeed, but that’s my job. And never blame them, never. The worst possible situation—the deadest, most hostile crowd—I don’t care. It’s still my puzzle. That’s a professional attitude that I’d never ever compromise.”

Seinfeld understands this fundamental performance truth: the room is feedback, not fuel. 

It’s not the audience’s responsibility to fuel your energy or drive your performance. (Of course, an enthusiastic audience can certainly enhance the experience—but it’s not a prerequisite for your success.) 

In fact, as speakers, it’s dangerous to depend on the audience for your energy. And it’s even more dangerous to blame them when your performance doesn’t land as well as you’d hoped. 

Your Responsibility as a Professional Speaker 

When a speaker walks offstage and says, “It just wasn't a great audience tonight,” or “the audience seemed off,” they’re implying that the audience’s engagement is outside of their control. 

Of course, you can’t control everything onstage. Sometimes you’re scheduled to speak right after lunch, when your tired audience is smack dab in the middle of the afternoon slump. There are poor seating arrangements, curiously designed stages, and unexpected mishaps

But amidst it all, you do have the ability and, in fact, the responsibility to engage, entertain, inspire, motivate, teach, and move your audience. This doesn’t just happen the moment you step onstage. Crafting a speech and a performance that achieves all those things requires an intense amount of preparation

Your core responsibility as a professional speaker is to fully design and execute a transformational experience for your audience. Your task is to shift their emotions and create memorable, insightful, and entertaining moments for them. 

That can only be done when you take responsibility for the cause and effect of what you do onstage and how the audience engages with it, then analyze the translation between those two elements—instead of blaming the audience for any translation errors.

The audience’s only job is to show up (and follow the basic, unspoken social rules of being an audience member). They’re not there to perform, or bring their maximum energy, or entertain themselves.

Full Transcript

Read Full Transcript
X Mark icon
Don't
get defensive—if you let your ego take the reins, you could start to become indignant or antagonistic towards the very people you’re there to serve.
Check mark icon
Do
keep your ego in check; stay humble and willing to learn from your mistakes.
Black right arrow icon

Three Common Diagnoses for a Poorly Received Message 

After a tough gig, resist the very natural urge to blame the audience. Instead, honestly assess your performance. 

If the audience felt flat and disengaged, ask yourself why. Finding the real issue—whether it’s in your content, delivery, or performance—is essential to iterating your speech. Carefully assessing each gig will help you craft a product (the speech) that lands and earns you future gigs each time you deliver it

There are three common culprits for a poorly received message. With a bit of introspection, you can diagnose your performance and shift to action: putting a personalized treatment plan into place to nurse your speech back to health. 

#1 Thought Leadership Myopia 

Myopia, or nearsightedness, prevents you from seeing distant objects clearly. Thus, thought leadership myopia is a focus on the self, rather than the audience and what they need. 

During one virtual session of GRAD | Speech Writing Mastery, one now-Alumni shared: “Over the past few years I’ve been doing speeches and I’ve never thought about the audience or Core Message. It was just I, I, I.” 

This is a very common problem in the speaking world—often, speeches are not designed with the audience in mind. The result? Messages overly focused on the speaker’s own story, accolades, or opinions—that don’t truly serve the audience. These speakers can see their world, but their vision and knowledge of their audience and their problems is blurry. 

At HEROIC, we constantly remind students that, to be effective, speeches must be developed with a focus on a specific audience and a specific problem they face. Every story, every case study, every word you share onstage is to help your audience overcome the problem and find a solution. 

When speeches miss the mark, it’s often because they aren’t entirely focused on serving the audience. To see if this is the case: 

  • Do a pronoun check. Go through your script and see which pronouns you use most—if it’s “I” or “me,” you might be suffering from thought leadership myopia. 
  • Assess your stories and anecdotes. Are your stories self-serving? Can your audience see themselves in your story? Do you clearly connect your anecdotes to your bigger message with a moment of reflection? 
  • Rewatch the recording of your presentation. Are your words, movement, and actions intentionally focused on the audience? Judging from the audience’s response, do you think they’re feeling what you’re trying to make them feel

Sometimes the actions speakers play onstage don’t match what they intended. For example, a speaker might stage a speech a certain way to help the audience better understand the message—but when they step onstage, nervousness takes over and they fall back into self-soothing movements (like pacing the stage or constantly shifting weight from one foot to the other). 

In the moment, their focus shifts from the audience to themselves, and often, they don’t realize this until watching the recording of their performance. Your job onstage is to stay completely focused on serving your audience—the more you put them first, the better your results will be.

X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do

#2 Audience Misalignment

Comedians perform to entertain, to get the laugh. Professional speakers can and should entertain as well—but it’s not their primary objective. Your main goal as a professional speaker is to deliver a transformational experience at the crossroads of entertainment and insight. To change how your audience feels and thinks, in order to inspire them to act. 

For that reason, it’s essential you identify the right audience for your speech. Your message is not for everyone. Even the most entertaining and expert mergers and acquisitions speaker likely won’t appeal to a group of pediatricians (that is, unless they’re going through a merger or acquisition). 

While there’s no such thing as a bad crowd, you do need to choose the right crowd. Your speech was written for a specific audience in mind, meaning it will be most effective and impactful for the people it’s intended for.  

There’s one clear giveaway you have a mismatched audience: the people listening do not have the problem your speech solves. You might realize this is happening when: 

  • They ask questions unrelated to or outside of the realm of your talk (these questions reveal the actual problems they face).
  • The stories, case studies, and pain points you share don’t align with their lived experience. 
  • You receive feedback that is vague or neutral—their comments can seem like they “just didn’t get it.”

When this happens, your message doesn’t hit the mark—not because it’s not valuable, but rather because it’s not something your audience is experiencing or needs at that moment.

Diagnosing audience mismatch can help you refine your positioning, get in front of more aligned audiences, and find that message-market fit. 

X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do

No Name

First Name
Last Name
Email address
Who referred you?
First & Last Name
Checkmark icon
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

#3 A Shaky Progression of Understanding 

If you’ve correctly identified your audience and crafted a message that’s focused on them, but your speech still doesn’t land, it could be because you didn’t effectively make the case for your Core Message. 

The good news is: you’re probably just a few steps away from convincing your audience to adopt and implement your ideas and proposed solutions. 

In GRAD | Speech Writing Mastery, students learn how to design a solid progression of understanding: the path you create to guide your audience as they learn, understand, and shift their thinking to finally accept and adopt your Core Message. This involves meeting them where they are, identifying and understanding the problem they face, creating the right mindset shift to help them understand the change, and guiding them to the promised solution and outcome. 

It’s kind of like being a video game designer. If you build a room where the player needs to be able to fly in order to get to the next level—but you haven’t given them the ability to fly—adjustments need to be made. Focusing on your audience, their experience, and their emotional and intellectual progress is essential for a transformational speech. 

To fix a faulty progression of understanding in your speech, review your speech structure and outline, then:

  • Ask yourself: What does my audience need to understand first, then next, then next, to accept and act upon my Core Message? 
  • Go through your teaching points. Are you missing an essential teaching point that will help you make your case? 
  • Do an invited rehearsal and ask the following questions: (1) During which areas of the speech did you start to doubt me, the speaker? (2) Where did you start to doubt your own ability to do what I’m calling on you to do? 
  • Watch your speech recording. Follow your progression of understanding and see your audience’s reactions. Where do they nod in agreement? Where do they seem confused, disengaged, or in disagreement?  

Based on that feedback, look for specific areas of your speech where you can address your audience’s doubts before they arise. When you clearly make the case for your Core Message in a way that makes sense to your audience, your speech will powerfully connect, impact, and transform your audience. 

Own Your Performance 

Once you accurately diagnose your performance, you’ll be able to implement changes to make your message more engaging, persuasive, and impactful.

Take this as a call to action for you, as a speaker, to own your performance fully. Embrace the fact that you are the undeniable source of energy, engagement, and entertainment. Seize the joy and opportunity embedded in every moment onstage.

Here at HEROIC, we often remind our students that the audience will never have more fun than you’re having onstage. That’s the essence of performance: the transfer of emotion from the performer to the audience.

Not only does this serve your audience, it also enriches your own experience. Your enthusiasm becomes infectious. You’re seen as a passionate, vibrant thought leader. You win the hearts and minds of your audience. 

And that’s what truly transforms the audience. 

X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do

|

Elevate the way you share your message.

CORE

|

The Breakthrough Experience

A high-level, fully immersive, in-the-room communications training experience for speakers, leaders, entrepreneurs, and creatives.
Learn more

First Name
First Name
Last Name
Last Name
Email address
Email address
Who referred you?
First & Last Name
Checkmark icon
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Three Common Diagnoses for a Poorly Received Message 

After a tough gig, resist the very natural urge to blame the audience. Instead, honestly assess your performance. 

If the audience felt flat and disengaged, ask yourself why. Finding the real issue—whether it’s in your content, delivery, or performance—is essential to iterating your speech. Carefully assessing each gig will help you craft a product (the speech) that lands and earns you future gigs each time you deliver it

There are three common culprits for a poorly received message. With a bit of introspection, you can diagnose your performance and shift to action: putting a personalized treatment plan into place to nurse your speech back to health. 

#1 Thought Leadership Myopia 

Myopia, or nearsightedness, prevents you from seeing distant objects clearly. Thus, thought leadership myopia is a focus on the self, rather than the audience and what they need. 

During one virtual session of GRAD | Speech Writing Mastery, one now-Alumni shared: “Over the past few years I’ve been doing speeches and I’ve never thought about the audience or Core Message. It was just I, I, I.” 

This is a very common problem in the speaking world—often, speeches are not designed with the audience in mind. The result? Messages overly focused on the speaker’s own story, accolades, or opinions—that don’t truly serve the audience. These speakers can see their world, but their vision and knowledge of their audience and their problems is blurry. 

At HEROIC, we constantly remind students that, to be effective, speeches must be developed with a focus on a specific audience and a specific problem they face. Every story, every case study, every word you share onstage is to help your audience overcome the problem and find a solution. 

When speeches miss the mark, it’s often because they aren’t entirely focused on serving the audience. To see if this is the case: 

  • Do a pronoun check. Go through your script and see which pronouns you use most—if it’s “I” or “me,” you might be suffering from thought leadership myopia. 
  • Assess your stories and anecdotes. Are your stories self-serving? Can your audience see themselves in your story? Do you clearly connect your anecdotes to your bigger message with a moment of reflection? 
  • Rewatch the recording of your presentation. Are your words, movement, and actions intentionally focused on the audience? Judging from the audience’s response, do you think they’re feeling what you’re trying to make them feel

Sometimes the actions speakers play onstage don’t match what they intended. For example, a speaker might stage a speech a certain way to help the audience better understand the message—but when they step onstage, nervousness takes over and they fall back into self-soothing movements (like pacing the stage or constantly shifting weight from one foot to the other). 

In the moment, their focus shifts from the audience to themselves, and often, they don’t realize this until watching the recording of their performance. Your job onstage is to stay completely focused on serving your audience—the more you put them first, the better your results will be.

X Mark icon
Dont
Check mark icon
Do

#2 Audience Misalignment

Comedians perform to entertain, to get the laugh. Professional speakers can and should entertain as well—but it’s not their primary objective. Your main goal as a professional speaker is to deliver a transformational experience at the crossroads of entertainment and insight. To change how your audience feels and thinks, in order to inspire them to act. 

For that reason, it’s essential you identify the right audience for your speech. Your message is not for everyone. Even the most entertaining and expert mergers and acquisitions speaker likely won’t appeal to a group of pediatricians (that is, unless they’re going through a merger or acquisition). 

While there’s no such thing as a bad crowd, you do need to choose the right crowd. Your speech was written for a specific audience in mind, meaning it will be most effective and impactful for the people it’s intended for.  

There’s one clear giveaway you have a mismatched audience: the people listening do not have the problem your speech solves. You might realize this is happening when: 

  • They ask questions unrelated to or outside of the realm of your talk (these questions reveal the actual problems they face).
  • The stories, case studies, and pain points you share don’t align with their lived experience. 
  • You receive feedback that is vague or neutral—their comments can seem like they “just didn’t get it.”

When this happens, your message doesn’t hit the mark—not because it’s not valuable, but rather because it’s not something your audience is experiencing or needs at that moment.

Diagnosing audience mismatch can help you refine your positioning, get in front of more aligned audiences, and find that message-market fit. 

X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
,

#3 A Shaky Progression of Understanding 

If you’ve correctly identified your audience and crafted a message that’s focused on them, but your speech still doesn’t land, it could be because you didn’t effectively make the case for your Core Message. 

The good news is: you’re probably just a few steps away from convincing your audience to adopt and implement your ideas and proposed solutions. 

In GRAD | Speech Writing Mastery, students learn how to design a solid progression of understanding: the path you create to guide your audience as they learn, understand, and shift their thinking to finally accept and adopt your Core Message. This involves meeting them where they are, identifying and understanding the problem they face, creating the right mindset shift to help them understand the change, and guiding them to the promised solution and outcome. 

It’s kind of like being a video game designer. If you build a room where the player needs to be able to fly in order to get to the next level—but you haven’t given them the ability to fly—adjustments need to be made. Focusing on your audience, their experience, and their emotional and intellectual progress is essential for a transformational speech. 

To fix a faulty progression of understanding in your speech, review your speech structure and outline, then:

  • Ask yourself: What does my audience need to understand first, then next, then next, to accept and act upon my Core Message? 
  • Go through your teaching points. Are you missing an essential teaching point that will help you make your case? 
  • Do an invited rehearsal and ask the following questions: (1) During which areas of the speech did you start to doubt me, the speaker? (2) Where did you start to doubt your own ability to do what I’m calling on you to do? 
  • Watch your speech recording. Follow your progression of understanding and see your audience’s reactions. Where do they nod in agreement? Where do they seem confused, disengaged, or in disagreement?  

Based on that feedback, look for specific areas of your speech where you can address your audience’s doubts before they arise. When you clearly make the case for your Core Message in a way that makes sense to your audience, your speech will powerfully connect, impact, and transform your audience. 

Own Your Performance 

Once you accurately diagnose your performance, you’ll be able to implement changes to make your message more engaging, persuasive, and impactful.

Take this as a call to action for you, as a speaker, to own your performance fully. Embrace the fact that you are the undeniable source of energy, engagement, and entertainment. Seize the joy and opportunity embedded in every moment onstage.

Here at HEROIC, we often remind our students that the audience will never have more fun than you’re having onstage. That’s the essence of performance: the transfer of emotion from the performer to the audience.

Not only does this serve your audience, it also enriches your own experience. Your enthusiasm becomes infectious. You’re seen as a passionate, vibrant thought leader. You win the hearts and minds of your audience. 

And that’s what truly transforms the audience. 

X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
X Mark icon
Don't
Check mark icon
Do
Education graduation cap black icon
Learn from
Alex

HEROIC

Speakers

Learn how to give speeches that transform how people think and perceive the world. We’ll teach you how to write, perform, and get booked.
Learn more
X Mark icon
Dont
Check mark icon
Do
white space
Loading
Someone is typing...
Person icon
No Name
Set
Moderator
(Edited)
4 years ago
This is the actual comment. It's can be long or short. And must contain only text information.
Person profile icon with blue background
No Name
Set
2 years ago
Moderator
(Edited)
This is the actual comment. It's can be long or short. And must contain only text information.
Load More
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Load More
white space